I think magical chairs would be more popular if this was an end possibility. Make it a double removal from the game: first, the person who didn’t make it to a chair in time, and second, the person they choose to sit with. The second person can stay in the game by doing X to the first person. Choose X depending on how horny/silly/friendly the game should be in your group.
Never lose a game of magical chairs again with this one weird trick!
I think magical chairs would be more popular if this was an end possibility. Make it a double removal from the game: first, the person who didn’t make it to a chair in time, and second, the person they choose to sit with. The second person can stay in the game by doing X to the first person. Choose X depending on how horny/silly/friendly the game should be in your group.