Japan surrendered not because of the bombs, but because the US and the Soviets were on their doorstep. It’s like when the SWAT team is outside your house and puts tear gas through the window.
Purely bombing campaigns can’t ever win an offensive war, unless you nuke the whole area and kill literally everyone, but then you haven’t really won anything. To actually win a war you have to have boots on the ground to take and hold the territory.
Although the NATO bombing campaign did end the Kosovo war, it was mostly a “stop it or we’ll keep bombing you”, kind of like Ukraine’s response to the Russian invasion, though Ukraine is not nearly as well equipped.
Japan surrendered not because of the bombs, but because the US and the Soviets were on their doorstep. It’s like when the SWAT team is outside your house and puts tear gas through the window.
From my understanding, it was primarily the loss of all their forces and the widespread firebombing, with the increasing threat of Soviet invasion, and the nuclear bombs (to a lesser degree) just being the final nails in the coffin. That said, again, they had lost all their forces in battle already, so saying the war was won by bombing is also a stretch - its just that between the firebombing and the nukes, it was the closest to an example I could think of.
Japan surrendered not because of the bombs, but because the US and the Soviets were on their doorstep. It’s like when the SWAT team is outside your house and puts tear gas through the window.
Purely bombing campaigns can’t ever win an offensive war, unless you nuke the whole area and kill literally everyone, but then you haven’t really won anything. To actually win a war you have to have boots on the ground to take and hold the territory.
Although the NATO bombing campaign did end the Kosovo war, it was mostly a “stop it or we’ll keep bombing you”, kind of like Ukraine’s response to the Russian invasion, though Ukraine is not nearly as well equipped.
From my understanding, it was primarily the loss of all their forces and the widespread firebombing, with the increasing threat of Soviet invasion, and the nuclear bombs (to a lesser degree) just being the final nails in the coffin. That said, again, they had lost all their forces in battle already, so saying the war was won by bombing is also a stretch - its just that between the firebombing and the nukes, it was the closest to an example I could think of.