Over the decades I’ve seen the praise and critique of the “Unix way”. I don’t remember reading about the aspect I’ll describe below. This might be a banality, and I haven’t invested much thought into it either. I’m just curious to hear your opinions.

At the core of the Unix way is that tools should do just one thing. Users very often need results that can only be achieved after doing several things. With only single-purpose tools at hand, users have to integrate them. In other words, the tool authors delegate integration to the users.

Here’s the idea I want to discuss. In programming languages, integrating various modules to achieve a goal is already a complex task because we often have to handle numerous failure modes and edge cases. In shell scripts this is much worse, since shells are more limited than programming languages. Writing a tool that does only one thing looks like avoiding the most complicated task. Which leads to a conclusion that the Unix way only works well in a rather small fraction of use cases; the majority of cases are better served by different approaches.

What do you think?

  • arty@feddit.orgOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    24日前

    Continuing the train of thought from the post: an approach that might serve you better is not a universal program that does everything. It is rather a custom program that does what you need. It very likely will apply reusable code, but in the form of modules instead of programs. It will be much easier to write well than to write a bash script well.

    • hendrik@palaver.p3x.de
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      edit-2
      24日前

      I mean that’s basically the same thing, just a different user interface. I think from a technical perspective it doesn’t matter a lot whether we write down the commands as text/words and connect them with “|” symbols or whether we pick them from a long list of symbols and arrange them as puzzle pieces or connect them with pipes or arrows drawn with the mouse.

      • arty@feddit.orgOP
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        24日前

        In my experience, programming languages offer more control than just connecting inputs and outputs, and it’s easier to get right