My first post on the Fediverse got a really warm response, but it also came with some weird political arguments, which is bound to happen anywhere.
I’ve believed for a long time that there’s no practical point in that, especially on platforms that sometimes bring together people from opposite sides against a common ENEMY. I just call it the Big Interest. We all have the same big Big Interest we disagree with, which is why we went looking for an alternative. The comments laid out the idea pretty clearly. People come to the Fediverse because they’re mostly or totally anti-corporate, they believe in a different path for technology, and they just can’t stand tracking and attention-driven social media.
I know I might sound naive, even dumb, but please hear me out.
- Say you’re politically intolerant toward someone with the opposite views. But you live at about the same standard of living, eat the same food, go to school in about the same places, hang out in the same spots, and doomscroll the same garbage. Don’t you share the same problems? The only difference is how you try to solve them. That’s it.
It’s more interesting to take the best from one side, then another, then a third, and build some kind of consensus. Listen to how the other side handles it. Interesting, right? Take their ideas and offer yours.
I like to boil reality down to something really basic: the left (liberal, whatever) pushes us toward progress, which is good, but bad if it’s blind. The right (conservative) tests whether that progress can hold up. So both sides balance the world, at least in my naive little worldview. Obviously there are way, way more forces in real life, but I don’t think shrinking or wiping out any of them is a great idea.
- Even if you’re sure you’re right and everyone else is an oppressor, a troll, or a virgin, doesn’t that make you exactly like your opponent?
I think it’s much more interesting when you smash your worldview into someone else’s and you exchange solutions. Otherwise, any political argument turns into an attempt to make your opponent into you. Do you want an army of clones? You don’t know where their beliefs came from, what they’re built on, how they changed over time, or why they ended up different from yours.
Personally, I’d much rather watch a debate based on mutual respect than a fight based on emotions, one where people try to cancel someone, corner them, change their mind, or make them look like a caveman, a bigot, or an idiot. Using those methods already shows that the so-called “right” side isn’t actually right.
- We’re kinda cooked, bro. The world we live in has gotten heavier, gone nuts, and is rolling downhill with no one knowing where it ends up. On our own, we don’t have the resources or the moral strength to face what’s coming.
Personally, I’m always for what brings different people together, not what splits them apart. I don’t think there’s any point in playing the atomization game anymore. It’s a waste of time that leads nowhere and gives us nothing.
The Big Interest, the one we’re all running away from to the Fediverse and places like it, has a moral flag built on grabbing total profit. And it’s totally shortsighted, too, because it doesn’t even care about the world its own kids will inherit. It has the money, and it has the tools to divide us. And those resources are insane!
I’m not calling for anything here, and who am I to call for anything anyway. But the imbalance is more than obvious to me. Everyone has their own way of cutting down that influence or getting rid of it. But one thing I’m sure of: we’re in such a deep mess that we have no real effect on anything, and the further we go, the worse it gets, because we’re so atomized. In my whole life I’ve never seen a force that pushes back and has to be taken seriously. I hope I’ll see one someday. I’d like to be part of it, or at least cheer for it.
What bugs me most is that there’s basically no such force in the world. Its shadow just fades out online here and there, and I’ve lost any interest in figuring out the truth in those arguments. Even if you find it, it won’t change anything.
Name-dropping never convinces me either: Putin, Zelensky, Trump, Biden, Kim Jong Un, whoever, pick one to blame for the system and all the sins of the world. The names change, but the idea stays the same. It just reshuffles the names. What do I care about any of these leaders? I’d rather dig into what idea they stand for and whose interests they serve. Where exactly do we even dig to fix things? I really doubt that after Dictator A, dictatorship will magically disappear.
-
Of course, none of this applies to political trolling, provocations and calls for violence.
-
My best friend and I, by the way, are almost total opposites in our beliefs, politics included. That doesn’t stop us from bumping them together, finding common ground, and having a great time.
Being politically intolerant in 2026 makes zero sense, especially when you’re all in the same boat.


I don’t know why you were downvoted; you obviously put effort into articulating a position that you are working through. Maybe it’s because of the community you posted to?
Well, screw the downvoters. Thanks for laying this out. It’s good work. It needs to be discussed. You probably aren’t alone in your formulation.
What I would say is that your formulation has flaws that, if you are open to being wrong, or even just changing your understanding (and therefore your beliefs), then you’re going to find a path towards something that is more accurate
The challenge with developing that accuracy is that we generally experience that development as individuals. Especially in the internet media world, you raising your own consciousness is not a collaborative process for the most part, it’s an individual one. And that’s somewhat fine - mass consciousness raising is the aggregate of many individual consciousness raising. The problem, which I think your articulation points to, is that if you raise your consciousness and develop a more accurate set of beliefs, you become one of the people that previously you were resisting or critiquing. And if that’s true for you, then it’s true for all the very many people who think like you do now. If you raise your consciousness individually, then all the people who think like you now suddenly see you as someone who has it wrong.
So to all the commenters who want to argue against your inaccurate beliefs, we’re missing a an opportunity to do something different here. Whether David’s beliefs become more accurate is far less important than whether people like David en masse develop more accurate beliefs.
So I want to ask you, David. If we can convince that your beliefs are inaccurate, but not try to impose our beliefs on you, 3 questions:
Discussion forums like this have a few modalities for raising individual consciousness: memes, debate, ridicule, and information sharing. Mass consciousness raising happens by virtue of doing these things in public for others to observe happening, or by using information sharing to organize deliberate communities of collaborative consciousness raising (like reading groups).
But if you could get 3 other people who thought the way you do, how would you go about collaborating with them to raise your consciousness together to get more accurate beliefs about the world? What would help you get there? What challenges do you face? What’s in the way?
Because I agree with you - nearly everyone you and I come in contact with are in the same group of people suffering under the same structural system that harms us and we all suffer together and we will all liberate each other together. The main difference is the difference in our understanding of the world and how we all relate to eachother and the world. If we can come together in order to co-produce a more accurate understanding, then we can be a lot more effective even in the face of differences in belief and opinion. We need movement towards more accurate shared beliefs.