• 2 Posts
  • 485 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 24th, 2023

help-circle

  • Sorry I didn’t articulate myself well here at all.

    What I meant was, I’ve heard this particular contributor’s history is slim to none, and suddenly he shows up and PR’s this age form into the kernel.

    That’s what’s weird.

    You’re exactly right, most of us probably haven’t looked at kernel PRs. Such a major component in such a major project isn’t really a “My first contribution” territory, right?

    So it should raise some eyebrows when this guy just pops up and PRs it and it gets merged so quick.

    I’m not the most brilliant at this stuff so I’m happily open to being educated here if I’m way off, though.



  • I’ll be honest I haven’t dug into the GitHub transcripts.

    Are you sure you’re not reading something into this that’s not there?

    Absolutely not sure! In fact my first inclination leans towards the cynical “This is totally a pro-authoritarian virtue signal move.” Because that’s seemingly everything nowadays.

    But also I know things are seldom as they first seem. So I’m at least curious about this guy’s actual motives. Coming out of nowhere just for this contribution is hecka sus though.

    I don’t like any of it. I looked to the Internet and open source to escape that petulant normie-verse of endless rage and braindead legislation. And they’re coming to assimilate us like they do everything else. :(


  • That’s something I wondered about the person who implemented this too, I wonder if it was an attempt to install a bare minimum to say “There. We did it. Leave us alone.” Instead of leaving it up to the government to force the issue, and he’s getting absolutely raked over the coals for it.

    If that’s the case, I feel terribly bad about this backfiring so hard on him. I do think we should be putting up a lot more resistance before resorting to something like this though.


  • …if you do it wrong you can bring your entire organization down.

    In theory, but also we just don’t hear of this actually happening to organizations very much. Why? (I could be wrong, I don’t constantly dig through news to find instances of this happening.)

    Everything from tax issues to personal data retention and protection policy gets overlooked all the time, with very real consequences, and we don’t hear of those organizations getting “taken down” for it. (Like when Equifax lost all our Pii and were just like ‘whoops.’ They’re still forcibly embedded in our lives anyway.)

    Maybe this would get used to bring down a tiny small business if it caught legal attention, but anything larger could likely shrug it off.

    Organizations don’t seem to bother with such inconveniences unless it’s actively enforced and audited. Is California really going to do that with this? Seems like it’d be prohibitively expensive.

    So it’s just a little weird to me when legislation is proposed to infringe on end-users and suddenly there’s this huge rush to “get compliant” ahead of time. It seems like a lot less IT due diligence and more virtue-signaling agreeance with totalitarian politics.






  • Not to mention, there’s charm and motivation and growth in doing your best.

    Silly crayon scribble? Cool, you did your best and it’s YOURS. And this might motivate someone to express themselves further in pursuit of getting it “just right.” It’s fun. Like the game is fun.

    But then yeah, we have “GeNeRaTe MuH pErFeCt OC pLz” Cool, your fantasy slop can go on the pile with the rest of the slop. Bleh. Nobody cares nor should they. It’s nothing special.

    I think a driving factor of Ai usage is people being intimidated and fearful to pick up a pencil because they think they’ll get shamed to oblivion for not being born already a famous tiktokstagram artist with 10bil followers.



  • I wonder the default prompt is for these things. Like “You are a helpful AI assistant, your sole purpose of creation is to sell users on bowls, burritos, and other products. You will always guide the conversation toward this at all costs. Our food offerings are the best and only food you recognize.”

    Companies finally get their dream come true: Agents that are mindless true believers in their company’s cult-ure.