• 2 Posts
  • 1.56K Comments
Joined il y a 3 ans
cake
Cake day: 11 juillet 2023

help-circle








  • OK, sure, but what are the actual, real-life consequences of that?

    uBlock Origin and any other effective content blocker had that as its most important weapon, without exaggeration. it has many other techniques for specific circumstances, but preventing to load the ad scripts, and preventing network requests that send back data to the advertising company, are universally a powerful tool.

    I don’t see any ads online. So ad-blocking still works. What doesn’t work?

    you don’t see them because addons can still insert unlimited cosmetic tweaks. CSS snippets that make specific elements hidden. but the ads are still loaded, consuming network and CPU resources, and the ad framework still collects usage, interaction and device data.

    also, the addons now can’t regularly update the lists even for what cosmetic tweaks to apply. google has decided it does not allow addons in their addon store that fetch filterlists from the network. this means these addons need to embed the lists in themselves. list updates are released much less frequently, and can have several days delay while google decides whether the updated version contains something malicious or otherwise unacceptable to their policies. compared to that, uBlock Origin on Firefox updates the lists every day by default, with no delay, as it fetches the lists directly from their websites.


  • Not part of any adblocker. Some, like Ghostery, have a separate mechanism to auto-reject these. I switched from uBO to Ghostery because uBO wasn’t doing anything against those.

    this is false. and instead of just claiming so, here is proof: there are built-in (but disabled by default) blocklists specialized for cookie prompts and such

    That’s not an adblock feature

    and as I said, uBO is not just an ad blocker, so saying xy ad blocker can replace it well is false.

    and there are hundreds of other extensions that handle that, like PrivacyBadger

    except that not really. Because again, the required browser APIs were removed, and even before that, privacy badger was not so effective

    Also: privacy related stuff is not affected by Manifest v3, no?

    everything is effected that:

    • needs to block network requests, including loading of certain site scripts
    • depends on an up to date list of things to block









  • first it was the news sites, then the shops and venues, but I didn’t speak up because I haven’t used them anyway.

    then the utiliies companies did that, but I didn’t speak up, so far as I can pay the invoices personally it’s not a big deal.

    then came the government sites, but meh, I can just go in person! sure it takes away many hours but it’s not worth the hassle to complain!

    and by that time nothing else was left either, because all the other sites dropped support in the meantime, while I did not have the time anymore to notice it.