• 36 Posts
  • 691 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 1st, 2023

help-circle













  • I disagree. Attestation is definitely not wrong in a corporate setting where you want applications to only run on safe devices.

    Taken out of the corporate world, it is problematic though, that I can agree with. But the solution shouldn’t be abolishing it without knowing why it exists. My guess is that there is a legal precedent or threat for it existing. Banks, healthcare applications and so on have a good reason to want to run in a secure environment. However, and this I’d where I think the alternative should be, users must have the option to opt out or say “I don’t care what you think, this device is secure, I will be liable for any damages to my own data should this device be insecure”.

    Unified Attestation might actually be the way to include an opt out that is legally binding. So, again, instead of just taking a hard-line “no, I’m right all the time, my opinion is absolute”, it might help to think critically about things and ask “why” and “what if”.







  • GrapheneOS with literally call anything shit that Gaelle from Murena touches. If Gaelle made billions and gave away an entire billion to an opensource project, GrapheneOS would whine day in day out about it. If Gaelle donated that billion to GrapheneOS, it wouldn’t surprise me if the disbanded or gave that billion away in order not to be associated with the money.

    Attestation is definitely a tool to lock people in, but it has valid usecases that cannot just be ignored. For example, it claims to ensure that the device is safe, to a certain degree, from malware and tampering that could lead to security problems for applications on the device. Those claims are part of the appeal. Instead of writing pages of slander towards the developers of Unified Attestation and, what I can only describe as, losing their shit, why not be constructive. Propose alternatives, propose to work on something better, point to a group that could help work on something better, throw out ideas for improvements, etc.

    A bit of drama is cute once in a while, but not like this.