I have been testing Tor Browser and Mullvad Browser using fingerprint.com. I get unique persistent identifiers that are unique per machine and persist over rebooting sessions. Javascript was on during this test.

This could be very dangerous to people using Tor Browser and Mullvad Browser.

For example, if someone visits Rainbow Railroad, an organization for leaving repressive countries with hostile LGBT policies, and then watches a video about the organization on YouTube, and then also does something, like create a Discord Server, and use Tor Browser to get around geoblocking but link it to their personal phone number, then a hostile regime buying data from data brokers could possible determine that user is considering using rainbow railroad. Even if this exact example isn’t realistic or plausible (although governments do buy form data brokers), users should be aware that persistent identifiers in Tor Browser and Mullvad Browser allow for continuous tracking of a user using the same machine.

I posted this information on privacyguides forum and they deleted my account after, leading me to wonder if the forum is a giant honeypot that curates acceptable privacy discussions and unacceptable private discussions. I honestly wonder if they are infiltrated by the government. They repeatedly delete the posts of other people as well and the whole thing is starting to not sit well with me.

  • doomguin@piefed.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    edit-2
    5 hours ago

    I was able to partially replicate, on safest mode with the minimum js enabled for a result to come up

    Tor on mobile gets reliably identified (not a huge surprise, but annoying) regardless of extensions

    Tor on desktop did not get reliably identified, even with uBlock

    Tor on desktop in “safer” mode, with default noscript, and uBlock enabled, was not reliably identified

    Edit: Surprisingly, even on “standard” setting, desktop was not uniquely identified