The idea of regimented excersice is such an adult drag. I went back to viewing it as a consequence of unstructured play time. Riding your bike, climbing trees, walking up hills and jumping around still count as being active. This way it can be spontaneous and organic and fun.
Or cattle prods … you could hire cowboys on horses to just ride into the office between the cubicles and cattle prod the people out into ‘play pens’ for a 15 min break … then herd them back once they are done.
I think the “especially as you age” part of the previous comment was important. Yes walking/biking/moving are good and healthy, but as you age you start losing muscle and bone mass (I forget, like a few percent every 10 years?). The only way to offset this is something like resistance weight training.
a real workout involves straining your heart and muscles so they are forced to become stronger to deal with the load. that is where the real health benefits come in. light exercise does none of that. all it really does it burn some extra calories. for light exercise to be effective it has to be endurance, as in hours and hours of it.
people may not like that fact, but it’s how biology works. it’s not exactly convenient.
If I get on my bike and ride 40 minutes I don’t think my body cares that it wasn’t done in a structured way. I like to go fast so its not like an evening stroll. Unless you are a body builder, you don’t need a strict regiment. Just an openness to push your body doing things.
Then take a 10 minute walk. Any amount of exercise that you can get in a day is better than none. The maximalist approach to it can be overwhelming and off-putting for people.
If you want to be healthy, you need to put in serious work. 10 minutes walks won’t cut it. Sorry that busts your bubble or whatever.
You are trying to say anything is better than nothing, and then using that as some sort of ‘just do the bare minimum’.
The cardiologist association recommendation is 150 minutes a week of medium intensity, or 75 high intensity minutes. That’s 5 days of hard work for 15m at threshold, or 5 days a week of 30m of aerobic intensity. That’s zone 3 or higher, which is you can feel your heart pounding and you are sweating sweating.
a casual bike ride isn’t aerobic activity, it’s zone 1-2. a walk is zone 1, it’s slightly above resting.
TIL my body will only burn calories and build muscle if I run at the same time and the same way every day, or get a gym membership and do sets. Better give up going on hikes, and biking, and walking in the snow. It just won’t deliver those Chris Pratt personal trainer results that every one has to look for.
That person is making lots of reductionist assumptions, I think you might be getting baited, you could keep replying to him but I don’t think anything productive could come out of this.
Yeah, cardiologists, physicians, and physical trainers… are all just full of reductive assumptions… lol
I mean I get it, people want to be lazy. They want to believe that drinking wine is and going for a walk is going to magically cure their lack of activity and poor diet. It won’t.
The only thing that cures those things is activity, and good diet. Sadly people would rather throw up their hands than take on that burden. Hence why the health/wellness industry is so full of snake oil and miracle cures people pay a lot of money for… instead of just going for a proper run and eating healthy food.
The idea of regimented excersice is such an adult drag. I went back to viewing it as a consequence of unstructured play time. Riding your bike, climbing trees, walking up hills and jumping around still count as being active. This way it can be spontaneous and organic and fun.
If only adult jobs had recess. Someone needs to ring a bell for everyone to go play freeze tag outside for an hour, then back to staring at excel.
Siesta is a real thing in some places.
It’s a “team building activity.”
…or “mandatory fun” as it came to be known around my work place.
Which…I get it…but I always appreciated the distractions from work…
I would prefer nap time.
Or cattle prods … you could hire cowboys on horses to just ride into the office between the cubicles and cattle prod the people out into ‘play pens’ for a 15 min break … then herd them back once they are done.
That doesn’t sound so bad.
Rajio taisō
Think some Japanese companies still do these warm-ups together?
We used to have a table football in ours office. Then we moved and took it with us. Then we moved again.
There is another around a few corners but it’s not the same.
with the exception of classes. I am a middle aged man who takes dance and sword fighting classes and loves it.
except none of that has the health benefits of structured exercise. especially as you age.
same with food.
You’re increasing your heart rate and likely getting sun. What more health benefits do you need? Sure a good stretch first “as you age”
I think the “especially as you age” part of the previous comment was important. Yes walking/biking/moving are good and healthy, but as you age you start losing muscle and bone mass (I forget, like a few percent every 10 years?). The only way to offset this is something like resistance weight training.
because it’s not a real work out.
a real workout involves straining your heart and muscles so they are forced to become stronger to deal with the load. that is where the real health benefits come in. light exercise does none of that. all it really does it burn some extra calories. for light exercise to be effective it has to be endurance, as in hours and hours of it.
people may not like that fact, but it’s how biology works. it’s not exactly convenient.
If I get on my bike and ride 40 minutes I don’t think my body cares that it wasn’t done in a structured way. I like to go fast so its not like an evening stroll. Unless you are a body builder, you don’t need a strict regiment. Just an openness to push your body doing things.
40m on a bike is nothing. that’s like walking 10minutes.
Then take a 10 minute walk. Any amount of exercise that you can get in a day is better than none. The maximalist approach to it can be overwhelming and off-putting for people.
It’s not maximalist. It’s reality.
If you want to be healthy, you need to put in serious work. 10 minutes walks won’t cut it. Sorry that busts your bubble or whatever.
You are trying to say anything is better than nothing, and then using that as some sort of ‘just do the bare minimum’.
The cardiologist association recommendation is 150 minutes a week of medium intensity, or 75 high intensity minutes. That’s 5 days of hard work for 15m at threshold, or 5 days a week of 30m of aerobic intensity. That’s zone 3 or higher, which is you can feel your heart pounding and you are sweating sweating.
a casual bike ride isn’t aerobic activity, it’s zone 1-2. a walk is zone 1, it’s slightly above resting.
That is also only focusing on the cardio side. The benefits of a structured workout routine is cardio as well as balanced strength training.
You are very unlikely to match the benefits organically unless you are already extremely active.
TIL my body will only burn calories and build muscle if I run at the same time and the same way every day, or get a gym membership and do sets. Better give up going on hikes, and biking, and walking in the snow. It just won’t deliver those Chris Pratt personal trainer results that every one has to look for.
That person is making lots of reductionist assumptions, I think you might be getting baited, you could keep replying to him but I don’t think anything productive could come out of this.
I had kinda assumed by the second comment, but I can’t actually help myself. I was born to argue with people and its why I am here.
Yeah, cardiologists, physicians, and physical trainers… are all just full of reductive assumptions… lol
I mean I get it, people want to be lazy. They want to believe that drinking wine is and going for a walk is going to magically cure their lack of activity and poor diet. It won’t.
The only thing that cures those things is activity, and good diet. Sadly people would rather throw up their hands than take on that burden. Hence why the health/wellness industry is so full of snake oil and miracle cures people pay a lot of money for… instead of just going for a proper run and eating healthy food.