I really must play with some of the modern lisps. I’m afraid most of my experience is with elisp which while it has it’s charms I wouldn’t call a general purpose lisp.
I think the most friendly modern Lisps are Clojure, and Racket, which is a superset of Scheme. Clojure is arguably the most elegant one, extremely well documented, very good for learning, and a pleasure to work with. Due to its larger start-up time and its fantastic approach to concurrency (with built-in immutable collections), It is more geared to be used in server implementations, but it has now implementations for many platforms, not only the JVM.
On the other hand, the more powerful Common Lisp implementations, like SBCL, are seriously under-hyped. One thing that is special about Common Lisp is that one can easily debug the running program. This is not possible in the same way in other languages, since exceptions usually destroy the call stack - in Common Lisp, you can handle the error at the location it is thrown, and re-start operations.
From the Schemes, I think Guile has the best debugging experience, quite similar to SBCL. It is also very well integrated with a Linux/POSIX OS, and can with little effort call system library routines in C.
I really must play with some of the modern lisps. I’m afraid most of my experience is with elisp which while it has it’s charms I wouldn’t call a general purpose lisp.
I think the most friendly modern Lisps are Clojure, and Racket, which is a superset of Scheme. Clojure is arguably the most elegant one, extremely well documented, very good for learning, and a pleasure to work with. Due to its larger start-up time and its fantastic approach to concurrency (with built-in immutable collections), It is more geared to be used in server implementations, but it has now implementations for many platforms, not only the JVM.
On the other hand, the more powerful Common Lisp implementations, like SBCL, are seriously under-hyped. One thing that is special about Common Lisp is that one can easily debug the running program. This is not possible in the same way in other languages, since exceptions usually destroy the call stack - in Common Lisp, you can handle the error at the location it is thrown, and re-start operations.
From the Schemes, I think Guile has the best debugging experience, quite similar to SBCL. It is also very well integrated with a Linux/POSIX OS, and can with little effort call system library routines in C.