I’m a lawyer that specializes in this area of IP law. It is true that code generated by an LLM lacks a human author and is therefore not copyright eligible material.
That sounds a bit over simplified? I thought the decisions so far were for cases with minimal human input but so far no decisions in cases where a person guides an llm or has significant input into the output.
The issue here is that the output must contain human expression to be protected. If you ask it to just solve a problem for you then you haven’t put expression in because that’s just functional use. And if it doesn’t respond in kind by preserving your expression then likewise there’s nothing protected.
On the other hand, if your start with clearly copyright protected works of your own like books or poem collections, then if you ask it to expand on it or edit then you’ll have much more of your actual expression in the output.
Or, if you simply only use the LLM output as a template and then edit yourself to make it yours.
The issue here is that the output must contain human expression to be protected. If you ask it to just solve a problem for you then you haven’t put expression in because that’s just functional use. And if it doesn’t respond in kind by preserving your expression then likewise there’s nothing protected.
Wasn’t that the issue with photography as well? “I just push a button” and the machine takes the photograph. Did I create that photo or did the camera? The expression was deemed to be that of the photographer in this case. But it’s the machine doing the actual work.
On the other hand, if your start with clearly copyright protected works of your own like books or poem collections, then if you ask it to expand on it or edit then you’ll have much more of your actual expression in the output.
Or, if you simply only use the LLM output as a template and then edit yourself to make it yours.
Right. And what if you guide the LLM through writing the code? e.g. “No not like that - do this instead” - or if you go beyond telling it what you want and tell it how to go about doing it? What if you have style guidelines that you want it to follow? How much of the code has your “expression” in it as a result? Frankly that can be a lot more work than “push a button and the machine does the work”. But whether that work is considered to be the “expression” of the developer or not… I dunno.
I feel like there’s a lot of gray area here. Everything from “just fully vibe-coded” to “coded along-side an LLM”.
The biggest case in this field about human authorship is the Naruto monkey selfie case, but for the cases youre talking about (human input and an LLM) there havr been a number of administrative law cases at the US Copyright office. The two most useful to read are Zarya of the Dawn, Thaler, and Suryast.
That sounds a bit over simplified? I thought the decisions so far were for cases with minimal human input but so far no decisions in cases where a person guides an llm or has significant input into the output.
The issue here is that the output must contain human expression to be protected. If you ask it to just solve a problem for you then you haven’t put expression in because that’s just functional use. And if it doesn’t respond in kind by preserving your expression then likewise there’s nothing protected.
On the other hand, if your start with clearly copyright protected works of your own like books or poem collections, then if you ask it to expand on it or edit then you’ll have much more of your actual expression in the output.
Or, if you simply only use the LLM output as a template and then edit yourself to make it yours.
Wasn’t that the issue with photography as well? “I just push a button” and the machine takes the photograph. Did I create that photo or did the camera? The expression was deemed to be that of the photographer in this case. But it’s the machine doing the actual work.
Right. And what if you guide the LLM through writing the code? e.g. “No not like that - do this instead” - or if you go beyond telling it what you want and tell it how to go about doing it? What if you have style guidelines that you want it to follow? How much of the code has your “expression” in it as a result? Frankly that can be a lot more work than “push a button and the machine does the work”. But whether that work is considered to be the “expression” of the developer or not… I dunno.
I feel like there’s a lot of gray area here. Everything from “just fully vibe-coded” to “coded along-side an LLM”.
The biggest case in this field about human authorship is the Naruto monkey selfie case, but for the cases youre talking about (human input and an LLM) there havr been a number of administrative law cases at the US Copyright office. The two most useful to read are Zarya of the Dawn, Thaler, and Suryast.
Thanks for the references!