Obviously fuck pedo, but in this case I think Ao3 is in the right.
Older Fanfiction sites are notorious for getting censored or taken down in all sorts of jurisdictions, based on whatever governments or banks arbitrarily consider taboo. Others are notorious for commercialization poisoning things. Ao3 ends that. The line is basically:
Must be fiction
Strictly non commercial
Cannot be fraud
Questionable content will be tagged as such.
And this isn’t like Elon Musk’s argument for Twitter or something where censorship is selective, bad shit is served to users without consent, where there’s a profit motive for it, and where content can hurt real people: Ao3 doesn’t recommend anything. It is an archive, for fiction. I am fine with fiction I am disgusted being on there because I don’t have to see it; but the larger policy protects the rights of everyone else.
a lot of times it was also the fanfiction sites themselves that censored “problematic” fics with arbitrary rules, often up to the site owner’s whims and with no connection to real-world harm. it got especially bad in shipping-heavy communities, which is still one of, if not the main group of users ao3 serves, because people get extremely catty about their ships and whatever they consider rivals.
for example, to stick to the bad faith pedo allegations the user above is making, imagine a YA fandom with 17-18 year old characters. say you write an entirely nonsexual, but romantic fic shipping a 17yo (during the og story) character with an 18yo main lead. maybe you even age it up so they’re 19 and 20. then someone who ships the same main character with another 18yo blasts you with pedo allegations not because they think you genuinely wanted to harm anyone, or even that you had the hots for a minor, but because they don’t like to see one of their ship’s characters shipped with someone else, and calling you a pedo is the best tool they have in their arsenal.
ao3 is basically where the community said enough to that childish nonsense (and many others, like some writers launching attacks on fanfics and such) and built a site that doesn’t bow down to that drama. it lets you share what you want, and it has a great tagging system so it lets you filter out what you don’t want. and it became the default in these circles over time because it turns out that acting like an adult is a better strategy than insisting you finally figured out who to witch-hunt and how, which is what the other sites were doing.
Yeah old school fanfic drama is as crazy and vicious as the old internet ever was.
And all this is without even touching on how homophobia, anti drug sentiments, etc could play into this. Ao3 dates back to 2008, which was a very different time for such topics.
I typically don’t really care for fanfic all that much (I prefer original fiction when quality is equivalent), but I support ao3 in their generally responsible anti censorship attitudes. The dead doves are labeled and you have to look for them.
Great, there are mods. But why are the mods allowing these horrible people to be on their platform and to use it to spread that shit? And no, the slippery slope fallacy is invalid here.
That’s the thing; they aren’t mods. Not in that sense.
Again, this is not a social media platform that pushes/curates stuff like Lemmy. It’s a library. It is generally not their job to be a gatekeeper; just to organize. It’s like how libraries often host controversial books.
Obviously fuck pedo, but in this case I think Ao3 is in the right.
Older Fanfiction sites are notorious for getting censored or taken down in all sorts of jurisdictions, based on whatever governments or banks arbitrarily consider taboo. Others are notorious for commercialization poisoning things. Ao3 ends that. The line is basically:
Must be fiction
Strictly non commercial
Cannot be fraud
Questionable content will be tagged as such.
And this isn’t like Elon Musk’s argument for Twitter or something where censorship is selective, bad shit is served to users without consent, where there’s a profit motive for it, and where content can hurt real people: Ao3 doesn’t recommend anything. It is an archive, for fiction. I am fine with fiction I am disgusted being on there because I don’t have to see it; but the larger policy protects the rights of everyone else.
a lot of times it was also the fanfiction sites themselves that censored “problematic” fics with arbitrary rules, often up to the site owner’s whims and with no connection to real-world harm. it got especially bad in shipping-heavy communities, which is still one of, if not the main group of users ao3 serves, because people get extremely catty about their ships and whatever they consider rivals.
for example, to stick to the bad faith pedo allegations the user above is making, imagine a YA fandom with 17-18 year old characters. say you write an entirely nonsexual, but romantic fic shipping a 17yo (during the og story) character with an 18yo main lead. maybe you even age it up so they’re 19 and 20. then someone who ships the same main character with another 18yo blasts you with pedo allegations not because they think you genuinely wanted to harm anyone, or even that you had the hots for a minor, but because they don’t like to see one of their ship’s characters shipped with someone else, and calling you a pedo is the best tool they have in their arsenal.
ao3 is basically where the community said enough to that childish nonsense (and many others, like some writers launching attacks on fanfics and such) and built a site that doesn’t bow down to that drama. it lets you share what you want, and it has a great tagging system so it lets you filter out what you don’t want. and it became the default in these circles over time because it turns out that acting like an adult is a better strategy than insisting you finally figured out who to witch-hunt and how, which is what the other sites were doing.
Yeah old school fanfic drama is as crazy and vicious as the old internet ever was.
And all this is without even touching on how homophobia, anti drug sentiments, etc could play into this. Ao3 dates back to 2008, which was a very different time for such topics.
I typically don’t really care for fanfic all that much (I prefer original fiction when quality is equivalent), but I support ao3 in their generally responsible anti censorship attitudes. The dead doves are labeled and you have to look for them.
Riiiight. Ugh I forgot about all that drama, but you are right.
Yeah, for all the criticism Ao3 gets, “the organization behaving like an adult” alone makes it so valuable.
Content determined to be pedo and/or incest should be banned and so should their writers. Fuck that.
Free press absolutists are pedo protectors.
Well hey I determine this comment as pedo and/or incest.
Please ban yourself promptly.
There needs to be a board of review.
I’m on the board: 👎🏼
(Just got my paycheck from usa company!!)
They already do. They have volunteer tag wranglers to tag pedo, and every sort of unspeakable thing.
Don’t want it? Exclude any keyword, and it’s gone from your view.
Great, there are mods. But why are the mods allowing these horrible people to be on their platform and to use it to spread that shit? And no, the slippery slope fallacy is invalid here.
That’s the thing; they aren’t mods. Not in that sense.
Again, this is not a social media platform that pushes/curates stuff like Lemmy. It’s a library. It is generally not their job to be a gatekeeper; just to organize. It’s like how libraries often host controversial books.
At least with the publishing industry there is some sort of filter that doesn’t let this garbage get out there.
Who pays them
Who pays Wikipedia editors?
“Won’t someone think of the fictional children!”
Actually, it’s “won’t these people PLEASE stop thinking about abusing children??”
Determined by whom?
An elected council.