When our child started cutting, we bought her left handed scissors so that she had both at had and could try it out. Her left handed dad - who grew up in a country which had no left handed things - wasn’t able to use the scissors. He can also not use a left handed guitar, he has played like a righty his whole life because a left handed guitar was unaffordable and “you need two hands to play the guitar anyway, duh”.
Anyway, she’s developing into a lefty, but no one is touching the scissors.
There’s many old left handed guitar legends who play on a right handed guitar for that exact reason, jimi hendrix for example. Tho he flipped the guitar around and restrung it basically upside down.
I also never really understood why my picking hand is my right hand when I’m right handed, I feel like I’m way more dextrous with it which would help with fretting. But at this point it’s what I’m used to I guess
I’ve done this with guitar on my early 20s. I’m righty and one day just decided to locked-in like Destin did to see what would happen. And like him it got to the point where something’s flipped and I could strum open/barre chord comfortably but didn’t get too far with melody though, picking hand is by miles much more awkward, orienting and holding the pick the right way is much more precise control than I thought. I could do decent enough legato to fool non-player.
Then I stopped for a week and it’s just gone, I didn’t become ambidextrous.
Picking requires much more control than fretting once you’ve learned the basic shapes or movement.
Think of the timing in it. The fret can be pressed at any time between two notes, but the picking needs to be exactly on time. Fretting basically becomes muscle memory while the picking is the real decision making.
Also think of the expression. Once you’ve fretted a note, there’s little to do with that finger. Bending and hammer-ons maybe, but it’s nothing in comparison to what the picking hand does. The picking can change the volume, overdrive, pinch notes, muting and overtones depending on position. Also of course timing as already mentioned.
Traditionally, it was probably chosen because of finger picking though. A lot of classical music is based on very basic chord shapes while the picking hand does all the coordination of playing both bass and melody simultaneously. That requires a lot more rhythmic independence on the picking hand than the fretting hand.
I’m left-handed for drawing and writing but everything else its a tossup for which hand I’ll gravitate towards. Some things I just end up equally not-great at no matter how I approach it
Her left handed dad - who grew up in a country which had no left handed things - wasn’t able to use the scissors.
That’s interesting to me. I’m a lefty who’s used to both types of scissors. That means I know how I need to pull sideways with the knuckle of my thumb in the right handed ones so they still cut well. But with the left handed ones I feel like I’m doing way less, I just pull and push up and down without needing the additional deliberate sideways pressure.
When our child started cutting, we bought her left handed scissors so that she had both at had and could try it out. Her left handed dad - who grew up in a country which had no left handed things - wasn’t able to use the scissors. He can also not use a left handed guitar, he has played like a righty his whole life because a left handed guitar was unaffordable and “you need two hands to play the guitar anyway, duh”.
Anyway, she’s developing into a lefty, but no one is touching the scissors.
There’s many old left handed guitar legends who play on a right handed guitar for that exact reason, jimi hendrix for example. Tho he flipped the guitar around and restrung it basically upside down.
I also never really understood why my picking hand is my right hand when I’m right handed, I feel like I’m way more dextrous with it which would help with fretting. But at this point it’s what I’m used to I guess
Backward bycicle, SmarterEveryday.
I’ve done this with guitar on my early 20s. I’m righty and one day just decided to locked-in like Destin did to see what would happen. And like him it got to the point where something’s flipped and I could strum open/barre chord comfortably but didn’t get too far with melody though, picking hand is by miles much more awkward, orienting and holding the pick the right way is much more precise control than I thought. I could do decent enough legato to fool non-player.
Then I stopped for a week and it’s just gone, I didn’t become ambidextrous.
Picking requires much more control than fretting once you’ve learned the basic shapes or movement.
Think of the timing in it. The fret can be pressed at any time between two notes, but the picking needs to be exactly on time. Fretting basically becomes muscle memory while the picking is the real decision making.
Also think of the expression. Once you’ve fretted a note, there’s little to do with that finger. Bending and hammer-ons maybe, but it’s nothing in comparison to what the picking hand does. The picking can change the volume, overdrive, pinch notes, muting and overtones depending on position. Also of course timing as already mentioned.
Traditionally, it was probably chosen because of finger picking though. A lot of classical music is based on very basic chord shapes while the picking hand does all the coordination of playing both bass and melody simultaneously. That requires a lot more rhythmic independence on the picking hand than the fretting hand.
I’m left-handed for drawing and writing but everything else its a tossup for which hand I’ll gravitate towards. Some things I just end up equally not-great at no matter how I approach it
That’s interesting to me. I’m a lefty who’s used to both types of scissors. That means I know how I need to pull sideways with the knuckle of my thumb in the right handed ones so they still cut well. But with the left handed ones I feel like I’m doing way less, I just pull and push up and down without needing the additional deliberate sideways pressure.