I see some fairly interesting prices for refurbished drives on Amazon, 35~40% cheaper than new. Example here: 16TB Seagate Exos X18 Refurbished at 166€ and New at 260€.

I am considering this option for my home NAS, running with BTRFS RAID10, plus important files are backed-up to a cloud storage, but not my media collection.

In your opinion, how risky is it to use refurbished drives ? Do you have to good or bad experience doing so ?

  • vithigar@lemmy.caEnglish
    5·
    3 months ago

    I wouldn’t buy a new Seagate drive, let alone a refurbished one. Every Seagate I’ve ever owned died in less than five years. Every WD I’ve owned lasted until long after their capacity was so far outpaced by newer drives as to be useless.

    Anecdotal, yes, but it’s happened enough to me that I’ve been soured on them for life.

    • GreenKnight23@lemmy.worldEnglish
      2·
      3 months ago

      my first 1tb drive was Seagate.

      after a firmware update bricked it I swore off Seagate for life.

      I would rather eat a pound of my own shit before I’ll use a Seagate ever again.

    • Suzune@ani.socialEnglish
      1·
      3 months ago

      Most of these observations are subjective. I’ve had some Seagate drives that worked well but were very hot and wasted energy. On the other hand WD was crap so far, starting with 3 TB. Not because of quality, but because of power saving features that were a major annoyance to me (green and some blue drives). Red drives I had were mostly fine, even they wore out pretty quickly (Load_Cycle_Count bugs). They ran at 0% health left for a few years and had other awful SMART and on-drive controller bugs.

      Since Seagate and WD are essentially the same company and they lied about SMR before, I wouldn’t buy either of them.