If the human race just peacefully all agree to never reproduce again, the world would be a better place. People have made several animals go extinct and destroyed the environment. Not only that but we made several other humans disappear. And people have tortured and killed other people in every way imaginable. Now our crap is floating in space.
We are termites living in a tree and some decided to eat the trunk first.
“The world would be a better place” For whom and according to whom? It is nature of life to compete with other life. If humans disappeared, another species would eventually become apex life and spread globally causing damage, exploitation and extinction. How is that different?
Are termites bad? They destroy trees, but that is just how nature is. Trees destroy other trees by blotting out the light. Ant hives eradicate competing hives. All things take so that they might live.
We are the same. What is strange about us is that we also have the capability to understand and to change, and to self regulate, to learn how to take from diverse sources to support our wellbeing and the wellbeing of the whole ecosystem.
Is it right to get mad at a five year old for not understanding the consequences of their actions? The human race has been growing up very slowly. But collectively we’re learning. There is darkness here but there are also those who build lanterns that we might see and change the darkness. Start looking for the good in the world and you will find it in equal measure to the bad. That is worth preserving, and an even brighter future is worth building.
This line of thinking is straight-up just eco-fascism. Claiming the solution to the world’s problems is the extinction of our species is equivalent to claiming the solution to depression is suicide.
Obviously we should do everything in our power to stop doing the terrible things humans have done in the past, and to clean up the mess we’ve already made, but the solution is progressing as a species, not going extinct.
I wish people would stop acting as if we’re some kind of foreign invader or pest on the planet. We’re part of nature as much as any other living thing, and we have the unique ability to be protectors of the places we inhabit.
The false dichotomy between humans and the rest of the environment is the whole reason we’ve made such a mess to begin with. As long as we view ourselves as “other”, as different, we will keep making the same mistakes we’ve been making.
What’s actual facism is how the human race has destroyed this planet.
Your suicide example is a false equivalency. I think this one works better in a personal example. Two parents realize they have something in their genetics that if they have a child, it could end up suffering. Instead they do the responsible choice and decide not to have the child. My example doesn’t involve violence and is about prevention.
Humans have been different from other animals since the cognitive revolution. Once they figured out using tools like fire to dedtroy entire forests to make hunting easier, we are already different then all other animals.
we have the unique ability to be protectors of the places we inhabit
How does that make the billionaires get richer, though? Because if it’s not going to make them richer they will do everything thing in their power (which is immense) to actively stop it. (And I domeaneverything.
Oh if you think the problem is only billionaires, it must seem easy to solve. Billionaires are rare enough that they collectively own a small amount of wealth. Kill them all and little changes unfortunately. Millionaires are super common so they collectively own much more. Largely it’s just old people retiring who own everything. Old people own well over half of everything and they need their investments and retirement funds to keep going up.
The billionaires are the face of this evil, but they’re only the tip of the iceberg.
Yeah, I like to say that “we can’t just go to space, we have to bring the earth (materials, food, air), and the sun (power, heat) with us. We are not inseparable from our environment because we are our environment
I think they don’t like the idea that you have calmly judged humanity, thought about it with humility and respect, and decided that the species they belong to are a net moral negative.
I disagree strongly, but I respect your position and I understand it quite well. There’s a lot of ugliness and pain we cause. I’ve seen it up close and from afar, and it is immense. I’ve also seen the beauty we create, up close and from afar. They both make a lasting impression.
I choose to value the beauty more, and I believe in our potential to do more good than harm, but I also see that I might be wrong.
I think that your clear and fervent passion of thinking hard about what the right thing to do is would make you a pretty good parent.
As long as you don’t make the kid depressed by mistake with your antenatalist beliefs, and instead gave them the best chance to learn about the world in their own way like my parents did.
I don’t believe we should all die off, but one way I do agree with you is that I wish us to become devoted to preserving the biodiversity of the world and protecting it from us, and stop growing into it and smothering it as if it’s somehow less important than us.
Nature does contain ugliness and pain and violence, too, and that’s why I think humans are worth preserving, even though our own ugliness is worse because we can understand that we’re doing it and choose not to do it, but often we do it anyway.
I know you agree with me on nature’s value for one good reason: Frog. There are many frogs, many kinds of frogs, and they’re all beautiful, and we’ve killed a lot of them forever, and that’s a crime.
Hey, cyanobacteria made all this poison for us to breathe, I for one thank them! /s sorta.
It’s a fun thought, isn’t it? If the biosphere that oxygen killed had any sentience in it, it would be as if the Nazis had built a death chamber for the world, killed almost everything, then later we and everything we know evolved, breathing Zyklon-B as if it was natural.
Cyanobacteria. The Triassic-Permian extinction event (the worst one on record) was due to bacteria farts. Methane causing drastic climate change.
Human beings are a dick, but not the only dick. The New World Screwworm causes a profound amount of suffering, so much so that ecologists are calling to wipe out the species as a favor to all mammals.
My bet would be on cats? Those are a menace to every ecosystem they are released into… but I guess they aren’t releasing themselves, so their extinction count would just add to the human extinction count
If the human race just peacefully all agree to never reproduce again, the world would be a better place. People have made several animals go extinct and destroyed the environment. Not only that but we made several other humans disappear. And people have tortured and killed other people in every way imaginable. Now our crap is floating in space.
We are termites living in a tree and some decided to eat the trunk first.
Room temperature IQ take.
“The world would be a better place” For whom and according to whom? It is nature of life to compete with other life. If humans disappeared, another species would eventually become apex life and spread globally causing damage, exploitation and extinction. How is that different?
Are termites bad? They destroy trees, but that is just how nature is. Trees destroy other trees by blotting out the light. Ant hives eradicate competing hives. All things take so that they might live.
We are the same. What is strange about us is that we also have the capability to understand and to change, and to self regulate, to learn how to take from diverse sources to support our wellbeing and the wellbeing of the whole ecosystem.
Is it right to get mad at a five year old for not understanding the consequences of their actions? The human race has been growing up very slowly. But collectively we’re learning. There is darkness here but there are also those who build lanterns that we might see and change the darkness. Start looking for the good in the world and you will find it in equal measure to the bad. That is worth preserving, and an even brighter future is worth building.
I said we are worse than termites.
I appreciate your reply. It is full of hope for the future.
Well said
This line of thinking is straight-up just eco-fascism. Claiming the solution to the world’s problems is the extinction of our species is equivalent to claiming the solution to depression is suicide.
Obviously we should do everything in our power to stop doing the terrible things humans have done in the past, and to clean up the mess we’ve already made, but the solution is progressing as a species, not going extinct.
I wish people would stop acting as if we’re some kind of foreign invader or pest on the planet. We’re part of nature as much as any other living thing, and we have the unique ability to be protectors of the places we inhabit.
The false dichotomy between humans and the rest of the environment is the whole reason we’ve made such a mess to begin with. As long as we view ourselves as “other”, as different, we will keep making the same mistakes we’ve been making.
What’s actual facism is how the human race has destroyed this planet.
Your suicide example is a false equivalency. I think this one works better in a personal example. Two parents realize they have something in their genetics that if they have a child, it could end up suffering. Instead they do the responsible choice and decide not to have the child. My example doesn’t involve violence and is about prevention.
Humans have been different from other animals since the cognitive revolution. Once they figured out using tools like fire to dedtroy entire forests to make hunting easier, we are already different then all other animals.
How does that make the billionaires get richer, though? Because if it’s not going to make them richer they will do everything thing in their power (which is immense) to actively stop it. (And I do mean everything.
Billionaires are temporary.
They do not think so, and they’re very loud.
Kings thought the same thing.
Oh if you think the problem is only billionaires, it must seem easy to solve. Billionaires are rare enough that they collectively own a small amount of wealth. Kill them all and little changes unfortunately. Millionaires are super common so they collectively own much more. Largely it’s just old people retiring who own everything. Old people own well over half of everything and they need their investments and retirement funds to keep going up.
The billionaires are the face of this evil, but they’re only the tip of the iceberg.
I am unfortunately well aware. I don’t want humans extinct, but man I would love if billionaires would just fuck off and die already.
Oh and corporations aren’t people. The world would absolutely be better off if they didn’t exist.
💯 💯 💯
Yeah, I like to say that “we can’t just go to space, we have to bring the earth (materials, food, air), and the sun (power, heat) with us. We are not inseparable from our environment because we are our environment
Alan watts has a great little talk on this
https://youtu.be/k9IH9F-IiU8
Just because you can’t reproduce, is no reason to foist your failures on the rest of us.
Why would you assume I can’t reproduce?
Call it a wild guess. Regardless, I sure hope you can’t. You seem like you’d be a shitty parent.
Even though it is a wild guess, it’s interesting that your mind went directly there.
What would make me seem like a shitty parent? Another wild guess?
I think they don’t like the idea that you have calmly judged humanity, thought about it with humility and respect, and decided that the species they belong to are a net moral negative.
I disagree strongly, but I respect your position and I understand it quite well. There’s a lot of ugliness and pain we cause. I’ve seen it up close and from afar, and it is immense. I’ve also seen the beauty we create, up close and from afar. They both make a lasting impression.
I choose to value the beauty more, and I believe in our potential to do more good than harm, but I also see that I might be wrong.
I think that your clear and fervent passion of thinking hard about what the right thing to do is would make you a pretty good parent.
As long as you don’t make the kid depressed by mistake with your antenatalist beliefs, and instead gave them the best chance to learn about the world in their own way like my parents did.
I don’t believe we should all die off, but one way I do agree with you is that I wish us to become devoted to preserving the biodiversity of the world and protecting it from us, and stop growing into it and smothering it as if it’s somehow less important than us.
Nature does contain ugliness and pain and violence, too, and that’s why I think humans are worth preserving, even though our own ugliness is worse because we can understand that we’re doing it and choose not to do it, but often we do it anyway.
I know you agree with me on nature’s value for one good reason: Frog. There are many frogs, many kinds of frogs, and they’re all beautiful, and we’ve killed a lot of them forever, and that’s a crime.
Not as bad as cyanobacteria. Not yet at least.
Though our extinction event is the fastest one on record.
Hey, cyanobacteria made all this poison for us to breathe, I for one thank them! /s sorta.
It’s a fun thought, isn’t it? If the biosphere that oxygen killed had any sentience in it, it would be as if the Nazis had built a death chamber for the world, killed almost everything, then later we and everything we know evolved, breathing Zyklon-B as if it was natural.
Other species have made a LOT more species extinct than humans have. Just saying.
Are we, as a species, a problem? Sure. But the solution isn’t extinction…
That’s interesting. What species have made more species extinct thsn humans?
Cyanobacteria. The Triassic-Permian extinction event (the worst one on record) was due to bacteria farts. Methane causing drastic climate change.
Human beings are a dick, but not the only dick. The New World Screwworm causes a profound amount of suffering, so much so that ecologists are calling to wipe out the species as a favor to all mammals.
My bet would be on cats? Those are a menace to every ecosystem they are released into… but I guess they aren’t releasing themselves, so their extinction count would just add to the human extinction count
Cats count as humans, as you point out. But we’ve still killed way more than cats on our own.