Humans are apes. Apes are monkeys. Monkeys are fish. There’s no such thing as a fish. There’s no definitive consensus on whether viruses are alive. Nothing biological is as simple as people would have you believe.
some categories are monophyletic, like mamals, or dinosaurs. all descendants of mammals will always be mammals.
But some are paraphyletic, like fish/lizards. where it’s just our attempt to categorising things, like all descendants of fish are fish EXCEPT reptiles and their descendants. And all descendants of reptiles are reptiles EXCEPT birds and mammals.
so no, whales aren’t fish. but will always be mammals
There’s no definitive consensus on whether viruses are alive.
This is one that I wish more people understood. A cell contracting a virus is like picking up a strange thumbdrive you found in the parking lot and inserting it into your laptop. By itself, it does literally nothing. But combine it with a host CPU and some power, and you’re in for a bad time.
Well, that and the fact that antibiotics do nothing for viral infections. Knowing the above helps make that a lot more clear.
Then you have second and third order effects. Antibiotics helped fight off a bacterial infection so your immune system had more spare capacity to fight a viral infection? It’s easy for people to learn the wrong thing.
It’s like ivermectin and COVID19. Some patients improved due to it. All those patients had actual parasites that ivermectin killed. Idiots doesn’t understand that the parasite connection matter.
Thought about that recently: assuming the AI Bros are correct, and it is possible to sufficiently approach sentience with current or near-future technology. In that case, it would be fair to say that such a brain simulation is sufficiently approaching being alive for most purposes. Is the brain file alive when it is dormant on some flash drive? Is the combination of the brain file and a running computer alive? Is the brain file running on a computer, but with read-only memory alive? Is a person who is on drugs that block memory formation alive?
I honestly don’t think it’s possible to have a satisfying answer to all that. IMO, the whole thought exercise is bound for the absurd territory currently occupied by “what is a fish?” This technology will clearly challenge our thoughts about “aliveness” and sentience, but we may have to settle for the notion that there’s no hard-and-fast boundary. That is, at least where any philosophical discussion is concerned. However, I do think that we’ll have to eventually come up with some legal definitions for civility’s sake, which are bound to have some odd corner-cases; we’re already here when talking about brain-death.
I formulate it for myself as viruses being like a wrench of such a shape that, when it’s thrown into factory machinery, the factory cranks out another such wrench. However, I’m one of those people who are hazy on why viruses could be considered alive. (Maybe under a broad definition like life keeps the entropy out for a while to perpetuate itself?)
Apes are not monkeys, apes and monkeys are primates.
Ages ago in college I had a psych class that would give you one bonus point for every test if you wrote “Chimps are not monkeys” on the top of the page
There is too such thing as a fish! It’s just not universally agreed upon.
My definition includes humans and all vertebrates, and all species that are more closely related to each other than they are related to organisms in the Tunicata clade. My definition of fish is synonymous with vertebrate.
Humans are apes. Apes are monkeys. Monkeys are fish. There’s no such thing as a fish. There’s no definitive consensus on whether viruses are alive. Nothing biological is as simple as people would have you believe.
some categories are monophyletic, like mamals, or dinosaurs. all descendants of mammals will always be mammals.
But some are paraphyletic, like fish/lizards. where it’s just our attempt to categorising things, like all descendants of fish are fish EXCEPT reptiles and their descendants. And all descendants of reptiles are reptiles EXCEPT birds and mammals.
so no, whales aren’t fish. but will always be mammals
This is one that I wish more people understood. A cell contracting a virus is like picking up a strange thumbdrive you found in the parking lot and inserting it into your laptop. By itself, it does literally nothing. But combine it with a host CPU and some power, and you’re in for a bad time.
Well, that and the fact that antibiotics do nothing for viral infections. Knowing the above helps make that a lot more clear.
Then you have second and third order effects. Antibiotics helped fight off a bacterial infection so your immune system had more spare capacity to fight a viral infection? It’s easy for people to learn the wrong thing.
It’s like ivermectin and COVID19. Some patients improved due to it. All those patients had actual parasites that ivermectin killed. Idiots doesn’t understand that the parasite connection matter.
Thought about that recently: assuming the AI Bros are correct, and it is possible to sufficiently approach sentience with current or near-future technology. In that case, it would be fair to say that such a brain simulation is sufficiently approaching being alive for most purposes. Is the brain file alive when it is dormant on some flash drive? Is the combination of the brain file and a running computer alive? Is the brain file running on a computer, but with read-only memory alive? Is a person who is on drugs that block memory formation alive?
I honestly don’t think it’s possible to have a satisfying answer to all that. IMO, the whole thought exercise is bound for the absurd territory currently occupied by “what is a fish?” This technology will clearly challenge our thoughts about “aliveness” and sentience, but we may have to settle for the notion that there’s no hard-and-fast boundary. That is, at least where any philosophical discussion is concerned. However, I do think that we’ll have to eventually come up with some legal definitions for civility’s sake, which are bound to have some odd corner-cases; we’re already here when talking about brain-death.
From my understanding AI will become legally alive once a rich enough person falls in love with one.
Are you alive in between plank seconds?
Excellent question. Made me stop smoking weed. Your short term memory being temporary on holiday is horrifying.
I formulate it for myself as viruses being like a wrench of such a shape that, when it’s thrown into factory machinery, the factory cranks out another such wrench. However, I’m one of those people who are hazy on why viruses could be considered alive. (Maybe under a broad definition like life keeps the entropy out for a while to perpetuate itself?)
I like that definition
If you mean the life one, I’ve read it somewhere as an offhand remark, but it was long ago so can’t recall now who wrote that.
The wrench version, but an entropy-based definition of life seems like it could lead somewhere useful
Apes are not monkeys, apes and monkeys are primates.
Ages ago in college I had a psych class that would give you one bonus point for every test if you wrote “Chimps are not monkeys” on the top of the page
There is too such thing as a fish! It’s just not universally agreed upon.
My definition includes humans and all vertebrates, and all species that are more closely related to each other than they are related to organisms in the Tunicata clade. My definition of fish is synonymous with vertebrate.
Reasonable people may disagree!
Glad you specified this – my hagfish siblings were ready to throw down.
I mean fish is right in the name!!! Although i do also exclude jellyfish lol
And Swedish Fish, too. They’re candy.
I love telling people the largest fish in the world is the blue whale. Everyone gets so mad.
I hope you then hit them with “but the largest land fish…”