Moderation needs to be done with clear rules upfront so people know what they can and cannot post. Moderating based on downvotes compared to upvotes is a terrible way to moderate because it is horribly inconsistent and unpredictable.
Edit: and people in general have an overwhelming tendency to use downvotes to show disagreement, which is not the same as the post being bad.
and people in general have an overwhelming tendency to use downvotes to show disagreement, which is not the same as the post being bad.
While that might be the case in some communities, I don’t think it is in this one. People look at comics because they like them, and downvote comics they don’t.
And I don’t think votes are unpredictable either. When OP goes to post comic from this transphobic and sexist author, they know very well it will be downvoted.
I’m not saying we should delete everything with downvotes, but this is clearly a case of deliberately posting content while knowing the community will not enjoy it.
Reddit solves this with karma. Getting downvoted is a punisment, and so OP wouldn’t keep posting these comics to not ruin his karma entirely (which might even prevent him from posting and commenting in many subreddits).
The karma system has its own problems and I’m glad Lemmy doesn’t have it, but it also means we need to solve this another way.
By banning people from posting if the majority doesn’t want to see what they are posting. If I was in the minority of downvoters I would simply block you.
But if I were to invite people to Lemmy now, it would go like: “it’s amazing but there are a few people posting bad stuff every day and you have to manually block them to make the place enjoyable”
It’s not just me, it’s objectively the majority. And that’s excluding people who blocked you and thus don’t downvote you.
You act like you have some undeniable right to post whatever you want if it doesn’t break the rules directly, but you seem to forgot that the rules are there to make the community enjoyable.
Moderation needs to be done with clear rules upfront so people know what they can and cannot post. Moderating based on downvotes compared to upvotes is a terrible way to moderate because it is horribly inconsistent and unpredictable.
Edit: and people in general have an overwhelming tendency to use downvotes to show disagreement, which is not the same as the post being bad.
While that might be the case in some communities, I don’t think it is in this one. People look at comics because they like them, and downvote comics they don’t.
And I don’t think votes are unpredictable either. When OP goes to post comic from this transphobic and sexist author, they know very well it will be downvoted.
I’m not saying we should delete everything with downvotes, but this is clearly a case of deliberately posting content while knowing the community will not enjoy it.
Reddit solves this with karma. Getting downvoted is a punisment, and so OP wouldn’t keep posting these comics to not ruin his karma entirely (which might even prevent him from posting and commenting in many subreddits).
The karma system has its own problems and I’m glad Lemmy doesn’t have it, but it also means we need to solve this another way.
Let me guess: by banning people you disagree with?
This is just dumb and I suspect you know.
By banning people from posting if the majority doesn’t want to see what they are posting. If I was in the minority of downvoters I would simply block you.
But if I were to invite people to Lemmy now, it would go like: “it’s amazing but there are a few people posting bad stuff every day and you have to manually block them to make the place enjoyable”
It’s not just me, it’s objectively the majority. And that’s excluding people who blocked you and thus don’t downvote you.
You act like you have some undeniable right to post whatever you want if it doesn’t break the rules directly, but you seem to forgot that the rules are there to make the community enjoyable.
I suggest you try Lemmy.ml, you will feel right at home over there.
BTW I didn’t realise your name is “Majority” 😂
Brother, look at your vote ratio. Do you want screenshots? Or definition of the word majority?
The post you are literally commenting under: