I’ll be getting a Shift Phone for that same transition
I owned a pinephone, I own a pinephone pro, and I use GrapheneOS.
Linux isn’t there yet unless you want a sub par experience (which I totally get from an early adopter perspective)
I heartily recommend Graphene. I switched a few years back, and I have had no regrets. Issues with banking apps aside, it’s been such a quiet phone. I get to choose what to install. No mandatory logins for basic utilities, no convoluted hacks just to avoid seeing ads, no hardcoded spyware draining my battery. It’s just… quiet. I love it.
I’m leaning towards it. Maybe with the pixel fold.
Graphene is Android. Technically Linux but not what most people here would refer to as Linux. That said, it is waaayyyy better than any Linux phone for daily use. I hope that Linux phones are the future but right now, they’re mostly for tinkering.
There isn’t a foldable I would touch right now.
I have the Pixel 9 Pro Fold (stupid name) which is running GrapheneOS. Works pretty well. I’ve noticed GPS isn’t great and battery life could be better but other than that it works well.
With or without google play services? I’ve kept my default profile FOSS-only from fdroid, battery lasts all day, but I don’t play games or watch videos. When I switch over to the profile with google services, the phone will get hot just sitting idle after updates.
I’m using Play services. I do my best to avoid apps from Google play but I still have at least a dozen, maybe more. It’s quite possibly a drain, but also I use my phone through the day so the apps I’m using are often the source of the battery drain.
It lasts all day either way, but if I don’t use it then I’d probably get two days idling.
I’m considering getting one of those and trying CalyxOS on it. Do you have any experience with Calyx?
I use a Pixel 8a and it works brilliantly with CalyxOS.
Nah, sorry. The only custom ROM I’ve used is GrapheneOS.
I have a strong suspicion many apps do not like GOS’s restrictions and waste compute power on rejected access errors.
Fully remove background battery and data usage from most apps and your battery will be happy.
That said I’m guessing the double-sized screen on the pixel9profoldxlsuperduty hurts the battery life as well.
This specific phone is known for not great battery life, something I knew before I bought it. Plus various things I have running are chewing battery, which I accept (particularly around location tracking). If I stay still and don’t use it, the phone will easily last a couple of days. But that’s not what phones are for 😄
I’ve never had a phone that has lasted more than a single day without charging. That’s kind of amazing, honestly.
Motorola G5 Plus. 3days battery with app use, 5days if just mostly standby and occasional texting.
I was sad when I dropped it and cracked the screen.
Most flagship phones will if you don’t use them! I have a Samsung S10 with the stock OS that I’ve had for many years and the kids use it for listening to podcasts. It often sits on the bench not being used much and will last 3 days or more just idle.
Pixel batt is ass. My middrange samsung a54 out performs my flagship pixelpro xl in battery every day
It lasts the day for me 🤷. But it’s getting pretty low in the evenings most days. It’s fine, not great, but fine. I got it as Pixel Folds are the only foldable that supports GrapheneOS.
my Pixel battery is a lot better on GOS than it was on stock Android.
Same.
I rock an OG Pixel Fold with Graphene. It’s pretty good.
How’s the battery life?
It’s pretty decent. I have the battery charge limited to 80% and generally finish a workday with 35-45% left over after a night of streaming YouTube audio for like nine hours with the screen off. If you’re not doing that, you can definitely get a lot more out of it.
That’s pretty good!
I have a Pixel 10 Pro Fold that I put GrapheneOS on. I like it, and they’re around $850 on Swappa in new condition. This is the newest foldable that supports Graphene OS, since Pixel 11’s mostly aren’t supported.
If you want a newer foldable with GOS, you’ll have to wait for the new Motorola phones to release and hope their foldable model also gets support since that hasn’t been concerned yet. Also, they’re going to cost over $2000 based on the previous gen options.
Personally, I’m hoping my Pixel holds out long enough for Linux phones to become viable and get foldable versions. Will that actually happen in 3-5 years? No idea, but I’m giving it a shot
How’s the battery life?
Depends on what you’re running.
I have an always-on VPN and a digital wellness app, so they’re always running in the background. Same with Syncthing when I’m home and running one of its connected devices. Also, some of my apps require Google Play services, which is another battery drain
Because of these 3 apps, I think I use more battery than the average person. I also limit the phone to only charge up to 80% each night to help the battery last longer.
Keeping that in mind I generally start the day at 80% and end it around ~30%. I’m planning to get a wireless charger to have at my desk at work just to take stress off the battery, but that’s because I want to keep the phone for 5+ years
Also, I don’t use the inner screen most of the time. I mainly use it for DM’ing Pathfinder, reading manga, or when I need to run 2 applications at the same time. If you watch a ton of video on the inner screen it’s going to drain the battery faster.
Overall, I like foldables, but don’t get it for the novelty. You should get it if you’re already regularly needing/using a tablet and want something more convenient, but otherwise you might be better off with a non-folding phone, especially with foldables costing more
this is 3 days in a row ive seen someone call graphene or lineage linux. who is putting this idea in peoples heads?!
android is linux the way iphone is bsd. there is a gem of truth to it, but its a pointless distinction.
Hmm. Ok. I thought that since it used the linux kernel then it was basically a flavor of linux. But thanks for clarifying.
i mean, since linux is just a kernel, android is absolutely a linux variant.
but from a user experience having things like a terminal, running x11 or wayland, being able to compile your own software on device. those are things that come to mind when people think about “linux”
android basically has a heavily modified linux kernel then runs everything inside a container and it has very little similarity to desktop linux.
so while youre not wrong that android is linux, the linuxphones com is specifically about running traditional linux on a mobile device, and you wont see much discussion about android and its variants
Ok makes sense.
It doesn’t seem like a pointless distinction. Android literally uses the Linux kernel. It’s just not gnu+linux.
Alpine is not GNU+Linux, but most people would still call it Linux
And funnily enough Nura (which is used on many Linux phones) is based on Alpine.
Wow, TIL, thanks!
i agree with you in principle, but android is not what people mean when they say “linux phone”
Oh, I see your point. I didn’t notice what sub I was in, sorry.
There are not many Linux phones / Operating systems : Safish OS (Jolla phone, pinephone pro) PureOS (librem 5) PostmarketOS (now called Nura) Ubuntu touch
Android has really become a thing of its own If you want to stick with Android but usw a custom Rom graphene OS is probably best - for ease of use e/OS is probably suite good but it is really not that secure
A newcomer is PocketBlue. It’s Fedora based.
Does /e/ use any Google Services (I forget, ran it on a phone a couple years ago).
/e/os comes with microg. GrapheneOS doesn’t, but has an easy way to install sandboxed unprivileged play services if you want.
It doesn’t. They use microG
It uses microg to simulate playseevices
I can happily recommend GrapheneOS. It the best mobile OS I’ve used.
Nura (postmarketOS) is a promising GNU userland Linux phone, but it is relly far away from being a daily driver in my opinion.
The three I would recommend are GrapheneOS (being Android based, it will be the closest in app support to standard Android, however Pixels are pretty expensive!), the Jolla Phone (which runs SailfishOS, Linux-based but semi-proprietary, has the best Android emulation out of all the Linux phones due to using Android binary blobs), and Nura supported devices (formerly postmarketOS, uses a close to mainline / mainline kernel, supports Flatpak so you get way more options for Linux native apps!)
I would avoid foldables, they are more trouble than they’re worth, and the Pixel ones really aren’t too great anyways. GOS only supports Pixels, so I would aim for a used device, perhaps a 9 or 10 series. The “a” lineup are good too if you want bright and fun colours.
The Jolla Phone is pretty cheap, and uses easily replaceable batteries too which is awesome! I’ve heard a lot of good things about it, and it can run many Android apps well :D
If you want something with Nura, the most well supported devices are the OnePlus 6/6T and the Pocophone F1, which you can find used for very good prices! I have a OP6 and its OLED screen has aged very well, it looks just as good as my daily driver Android device. Nura also supports lots of new devices, like the Fairphones (repairable and supports sustainable materials and fair working conditions!!), even the latest FP6 is getting increasing support. If you want to try out the full mobile Linux experience, go for Nura since you will get the choice of Phosh, Plasma Mobile, etc., as well as Flatpak apps (the self-described “app store for Linux”)
If you have the budget to go for a foldable, I would instead move you towards purchasing a used (non-folding) Pixel to run GOS, a Jolla Phone, and a device running Nura (either a Fairphone or an older device that supports it). Foldable prices are insane and it would be a lot more fun if you tried out all three degoogled options :>
Thanks so much for the detailed reply. I do a lot of ebook reading, and I’ve always wanted something that folded more like a book, that I could have a page on either side like a real book and flip pages. I have an old ipad and it’s fine, but it would be more fun to have something more book-form that I could take with me wherever I go.
But you make a great point about this just being experimental at this point, so why not experiment with it. I’ve been intrigued by PostmarketOS (I really don’t know if I like the new name better or not - seems more generic, yet “Postmarket” never made any sense to me either). I’ll look more into the fairphone with Nura maybe. Thanks for the tips!
I have a Pinephone and a Pixel running Graphene OS. You really, really want the latter, not the former. I’ve never been able to get the Pinephone running well enough to daily-drive.
(No shade on Pine64, BTW. It’s the software, not the hardware, that’s the problem.)
If you are getting a grapheneos foldable, get the 10 - the 9 has an issue with the hinge sensor failing in 1-2 years of use, which makes front screen unusable, and the 11 doesn’t have support yet (and if google doesn’t get its shit together, may never get support).
Thanks!
I have been using GrapheneOS for 4 years now and I can’t recommend it enough. It has been the most stable and secure mobile OS I’ve ever used. In terms of foldables, I would stay away from them unless you really have a reason to.
as someone who is daily driving graphene os for about 8 months now, I can safely say that it’s definitely the best experience I’ve had with a secure yet functional OS. I bought a used pixel, installed graphene os, and bam, after a day or two, I was pretty familiar with it.
I can say, my bank app does work, albiet, only on a profile where I have google play store services enabled, and all the essential stuff, messaging, calls, gps, etc . . all work flawlessly.
I can’t get visual voicemail to work but other than that I second all they say.
Your easiest switch is probably to a phone running /e/ - it’s the most iOS-like phone. It’s Lineage (a fork of Android) that /e/ then adds their own home/launcher, and their own services to make a Google/Apple-like experience.
You could also buy just about any phone that supports Lineage
Other than /e/, I don’t think anyone sells phones with Lineage pre-installed.
Here’s a summary of how to switch to a phone that supports Lineage
Interesting. I’m learning a lot here. Thanks.
If you don’t like the default launcher for /e/OS (which is similar to iOS), other options such as Lawnchair are very easy to install.
My bank’s app doesn’t work with only microG, but their website is good enough, so I haven’t needed to install Google Play Services.












