At the same time, this industry has kind of done it to themselves. I get that developers are scuzzy and all of that, but people keep pouring into this industry so what should we realistically expect here?
The 2D/VN space is being flooded with slop. Porn games were starting to take off in the west, but if you look now it’s almost all slop.
Does that include for code? Seems about impossible now.
I think its about how. Using LLMs to write entire game sub systems, is a recipe for bloat, poorly optimized/hard to maintain code. We call this vibe coding. Its a problem. Devs who forgot how to code is a real problem. Studies are finding devs spending MORE time coding than less, mostly debugging.
But using LLMs to remind oneself how to most efficiently sort a list, or write a database query, its very handy. For our indie game dev team we have a strict rule: not allowed for full systems and classes, and all AI written code must be read and interpretable before we accept code merge requests.
I mean, there are so many of us that really like to write code. Sure, big corpos will shove AI on their employers, but I skip those games anyway. Passion project (indie) games are still full of human made stuff.
The manifesto specifically includes code. I doubt this manifesto will make any difference in that regard though. Cat is out of the bag.
Can we go further? No DRM? No needing a fucking internet connection to play a single player game.
This is why I fucking hate the ‘Souls’ games as they all needed that. I never once used the multiplayer feature.
I don’t want summons in my games! I bought a single player game! Leave me alone!
Wait, I am stupid. You can play the souls games offline? That way you don’t have any messages and that meme-stuff. Pretty much the perfect first playthrough.
I don’t think ai is the real problem. The real problem is executive greed. I don’t ACTUALLY care that a computer made the 3d model. I care a greedy little manager who provides no value fired an artist because he can save on wages.
As it stands they still do this, force a crunch to get a game out then lay everyone off when profits come in. Leading to workers not really seeing the fruit of their labor.
If you can’t be bothered to make your game, why should I be bothered to buy it.
As a society, we can’t even seriously boycott clothes made by children who occasionally burn to death…
But we need clothes and don’t need video games. It’s much easier to be picky about luxuries.
Next time I see folks rocking sweatshop shirts that cost $50+ I’ll try to rember that it’s actually cool, those are necessities.
It’s a good thing those are the only clothes made in sweatshops, it’s so easy to consume ethically under capitalism.
I think customers should decide what they want to play based on the merits of a project. People have been putting out slop (truly shit games, gacha games, asset swaps, shit ports, and now slop-generated games) for a long time. The tools didn’t make the slop, the shit designers/developers did.
Cool story bro. One of the major project merits I’m looking for is “did not contribute to corporate theft of art, the dumbing down of society, and the hastening destruction of the planet by using slop machines”.
Sure and other may be worried about making sure no one used unlicensed software to create their games or that no jews worked on it or whatever. It’s cool you have preferences, but they are just random preferences.
or that no jews worked on it or whatever.
Yeah man, avoiding slop games is absolutely the same as being a racist.
This is what slop does to your brain, folks.
You’re doing great at comprehension. You talking to me or performing for an audience? If you’re talking to me, fuck you. Deal with what I said and quit the ridiculous ad hominems. If you’re talking to the crowd I hope you enjoy your imaginary points.
Ad hominems? He quoted you directly. If you can’t defend the absolutely insane thing you said then why did you say it?
People demand teams be diverse, they demand games not have female protagonists, they demand teams not be diverse, they demand same sex romances, they demand no same sex romances. Just examples of random shit people demand of game publishers. I wasn’t calling him a racist any more than I’m calling you a pro-DEI, anti-woke incel who wants simultaneously exclusive same sex and heterosexual relationships. I was giving examples. Is that not clear?
ETA: the ad hominem was the bit about brain rot which was not relevant to the conversation, not an argument, just a thought terminating bleating for random internet points.
Careful with him, it’s his first day on the internet 😔
Of course we’re all performing for others man. It seems pretty clear from the sidelines neither of you would change your mind, so the goal of talking is to instead convince people outside the discussion to your side, which is also why things like not saying “no Jewish games” is just hurting you
The other side of a slippery slope (demanding a say in the production process of the media other people spend their time making) is often places we haven’t gone yet but are the next and inevitable step to the very terrible concept on display.
There isn’t really a way to enforce “meaningful” sex/nudity, I don’t think. It’s more like some sort of ethical guideline that would say like “sex for the sake of advertising is bad, go make a porno instead”
Not all slop is “AI” generated, but everything “AI” generated is slop
Is it still slop when an experienced developer uses AI to assist them with development and thoroughly reviews it and is ultimately responsible for the code?
Eventually, yes.
LLM’s require expertise to supervise. Expertise requires practice to built and maintain. If you have the LLM do things, you’re getting less practice in, which slowly degrades your expertise, which in turn degrades your ability to supervise the LLM.
It degrades your experience writing code, but it doesn’t degrade your experience reviewing code. Those are two different skillsets.
No, but then, a developer who is responsibly using LLMs as a tool in their IDE to do boilerplate generation kind of stuff, is fundamentally not vibe coding and thus it isn’t the case that the project is AI generated, just like AI assisted.
I don’t really consider them the same use case. The former is low or no effort while the latter is a skilled person effectively doing the same types of offloading they used do with e.g. Jetbrains tools, just levelled up.
Personally I think there is a huge difference between “generate the backing implementation of this interface/protocol I wrote” and “hey Claude make me a game”
That’s a very good way to keep your world very very simple for yourself. 👍🏼
I’m doing that unintentionally since I’m patient when it comes to buying games being sometimes few years behind.
And now with reports of some devs hiding it I feel more inclined to play my backlog of games and emulate old titles until the situation gets figured out to have more consumer transparency. Will be a while before I buy games released this year and beyond.
Yeah, there’s decades of great games that don’t have AI slop. I have like 20 that are still in the plastic because I never got around to them.
I’m doing my part :)
You don’t need a manifesto to get me on board with that. Way ahead of you already.
Ai is completely out of the bag. Trying to have a purist no ai stance is unrealistic. Its unavoidable to not use ai assisted software or view ai images.
Well, we’re fucking trying, it’s not easy. Help us help you, we need to know what games are made using GenAI. How do we do that?
Follow this GODOT Steam curator while you’re at it.
https://store.steampowered.com/curators/mycurators/?filter=mycurators&keywords=Godot&x=0&y=0
I’m going to play whatever is good. And that’s going to include games made with at least some AI. This is a lost cause. LLMs are a great tool.











